Website powered by

Stability of Vortex Heptagon

The configuration of n line vortices spaced regularly around the circumference of a circle is stable for n <= 7, and unstable for n > 7. The theorem was first proved by J. J. Thomson (1883) in connection with Lord Kelvin's vortex theory of atoms. However, for the case of n >= 7, his proof is wrong, and was corrected by T. H. Havelock almost 50 years later. The stability for n=7 still remained unknown until L. G. Kurakin & V. I. Yudovich successfully tackled the problem in 2002. The magical number 7 appears in an innocent inequality to ensure the eigenvalues of the linearized system are imaginary.

Proof:
J. J. Thomson, 1883 (erroneous)
T. H. Havelock, 1931 (without n=7)
L. G. Kurakin & V. I. Yudovich, 2002 (n=7)

Experiments:
A. M. Mayer, 1878 (floating magnets)
E. Yarmchuk, M. Gordon & R. Packard, 1979 (superfluid helium)
D. Durkin & J. Fajans, 2000 (Malmberg-Penning trap)

Stability of Vortex Heptagon

Stability of Vortex Heptagon

The experiment of Mayer (1878)

The experiment of Mayer (1878)

Stable equilibrium configurations found by Mayer

Stable equilibrium configurations found by Mayer

Photographic study of Mayer's floating magnets (L. Derr, 1909)

Photographic study of Mayer's floating magnets (L. Derr, 1909)